Essay Instructions: Literature Review
Identify and locate at least five qualitative research articles on your topic. Try to include as many qualitative articles as possible. Prepare and submit a brief literature review of the articles that you locate. This should be an integrated review, reflecting specific details about the research articles within an organized review that demonstrates your understanding of the existing literature on the topic. Your literature review is expected to describe existing research and knowledge about your topic. Other learners will give you feedback through a peer review of your literature review in u03d1. Post your literature review to u03d1 for peer review.
Within your integrated literature review, be sure to address the following for each of the articles you reviewed:
• Identification of philosophical tradition.
• Identification of setting.
• Identification of research purpose.
• Identification of data collection method.
• Identification of researcher biases.
• Identification of an area or areas that would benefit from expansion or clarification.
Remember, the literature review must be written as an integrated review of the literature, not as five separate article reviews. You might want to organize your literature review by themes or subtopics within your broader topic, or if you have a combination of qualitative and quantitative studies in the review, you might want to organize the literature according to the research approach. Your integrated review should demonstrate some organization other than a discussion of each individual article.
SCORING GUIDE
Use the following scoring guide, along with the project information, for evaluating each learner's work.
Identify and locate at least five qualitative research articles on your topic. Try to include as many qualitative articles as possible. Prepare and submit a brief literature review of the articles that you locate. This should be an integrated review, reflecting specific details about the research articles within an organized review that demonstrates your understanding of the existing literature on the topic. Your literature review is expected to describe existing research and knowledge about your topic. Other learners will give you feedback through a peer review of your literature review in u03d1. Post your literature review to u03d1 for peer review.
Within your integrated literature review, be sure to address the following for each of the articles you reviewed:
• Identification of philosophical tradition.
• Identification of setting.
• Identification of research purpose.
• Identification of data collection method.
• Identification of researcher biases.
• Identification of an area or areas that would benefit from expansion or clarification.
Remember, the literature review must be written as an integrated review of the literature, not as five separate article reviews. You might want to organize your literature review by themes or subtopics within your broader topic, or if you have a combination of qualitative and quantitative studies in the review, you might want to organize the literature according to the research approach. Your integrated review should demonstrate some organization other than a discussion of each individual article.
Note: Your instructor may also use the Writing Feedback Tool to provide feedback on your writing. In the tool, click on the linked resources for helpful writing information.
Checklist Item No Yes Comments
Identifies at least 5 qualitative research articles.
(10%)
Submits an integrated literature review.
(10%)
Includes at least 5 peer-reviewed, qualitative research articles to be used in the Research Proposal project.
(10%)
Describes existing research and knowledge about the chosen topic.
(10%)
Identifies philosophical traditions of research articles within an integrated review.
(10%)
Identifies the settings of research studies reviewed.
(10%)
Identifies the purpose of the research articles reviewed.
(10%)
Identifies the data collection methods of the research studies reviewed.
(10%)
Identifies researcher biases for the studies reviewed.
(10%)
Identifies areas that would benefit from expansion or clarification of the research.
(10%)
PAPER TOPIC/RESEARCH QUESTIONS
According to Creswell (2007), “we conduct qualitative research because a problem or issue needs to be explored” (pg. 39). Researchers explore a phenomenon because of a “need to study a group or population, identify variables that can be measured, or hear silenced voices” (2007, pg. 40). Researchers ask open-ended questions to allow the participants to tell their stories, and to gain a deeper understanding of the problem (Creswell, 2007). The questions may change during the process, as the researcher gains clarity through the interviews (2007).
10 Qualitative Research Questions: “Experiences of an African American Mom who has experienced the suicide of a Son”
What are the attitudes and perceptions about suicide among AA moms who have experienced the suicide of male child?
How do mom’s who have experienced the suicide of son define religion? Spirituality?
How does religion and spirituality operate in the daily lives of AA mom’s that have experienced the suicide of a male child?
What are common themes in AA community about suicide?
How does suicide “reframe” the mother’s views after the death of a child to suicide?
What is the lived experience of an AA mom who has lost a male child to suicide?
How do AA mom’s who have experienced the suicide of a male child rationalize the suicide to themselves? Family? Friends/Community?
What was the initial response of AA mom’s who have experienced the suicide of a male child?
What kind of support did AA mom’s who have experienced the suicide of a male child seek in the community?
What do AA mom’s who have experienced the death of a male child need from the community? Family? Friends?
Reference:
Creswell, J. W. (2007). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Maxwell suggests Nine Arguments for a Qualitative Proposal (Creswell, 2007). They include:
We need to better understand, “The experiences of African American mother’s who have lost a male child to suicide.”
We know little about the dynamics that complicate the death of a child to suicide, specifically in the African American community. There are cultural and spiritual factors that prevent open dialogue about suicide in the African American Community (Gibbs, 1997). It is a community that places a heavy emphasis on spirituality and faith (Carlson & Sperry, 2000). Suicide is viewed as a weakness, and the “unforgiveable” sin (Gibbs, 1997).
I propose to study the real experiences of African American mother’s that have lost a male child to suicide. There are many underlying cultural and spiritual factors that make this dialogue “taboo.” Researchers explore a phenomenon because of a “need to study a group or population, identify variables that can be measured, or hear silenced voices” (2007, pg. 40). Often the voices in suicide are silenced for several reasons. Many family members express shame, denial and betrayal after learning of the suicide (Gibbs, 1997). They do not want to openly discuss the subject, and prefer to just move on with their lives (1997). T
The setting and participants are appropriate for this study and will consist of African American Mother’s who have lost a male child to suicide. The interviews will take place in a natural setting (homes or churches) and will give the researcher an opportunity to talk face-to-face and observe and see the participants living within their own context (Creswell, 2007).
The methods I plan to use will provide the data I need to answer the research questions. Individual focus group interviews, observations, confidential surveys will provide the preliminary data needed to answer the research questions. Creswell (2007) encourages the use of multiple sources of data to assist the qualitative researcher to discover codes, themes, categories and larger dimensions (Creswell, 2007).
Analysis will generate answers to these questions, as the multiple realities of African American mother’s that have experienced the suicide of a male child will be explored to discover trends, themes, and differences. These multiple realities will allow the researcher to uncover physical, emotional, psychological and spiritual barriers that may impede the healing process.
The findings will be validated by the use of triangulation and confirmation data from several sources, allowing participants to review and correct data, allowing other researchers to review data to review procedure and external auditors (Creswell, 2007). It is imperative that researchers allow the participants to accurately tell their own stories and accurately record and transcribe field notes and recordings (Creswell, 2009). Participants will be allowed to review the completed project. Creswell also suggests the use of other of readers, graduate committee members, editorial board members and reviewers (2009).
The study poses no serious ethical problems. The IRB Board will review all necessary documents. All participants will sign a confidentiality agreement, and will have access to review the research. All client information will be kept strictly confidential.
The preliminary results will support the practicability and value of the study. Research themes, codes and categories will emerge and allow African American mother’s who have experienced the suicide of a child to have a voice, and face spiritual, emotional and physical barriers.