Amendment Proposal Term Paper

PAGES
3
WORDS
911
Cite

War Powers Act of 1973 was an important piece of legislation during the Vietnam War. The intention, per the wording of the act itself, was "to fulfill the intent of the framers of the Constitution of the United States and insure that the collective judgment of both the Congress and the President will apply to the introduction of United States Armed Forces into hostilities, or into situations where imminent involvement in hostilities is clearly indicate by the circumstances, and to the continued use of such forces in hostilities in such situations" (War). The Act required that if armed forces were sent into a nation, Congress had to be informed within 48 hours. Additionally, armed forces could not remain within a nation for more than 60 days without a declaration of war. Those in support of the law promised the American citizens that the Act would prevent "another Vietnam" and restore the intended balance of powers in the government (Rostow 1). During the Vietnam War, thousands of troops were sent in without an official declaration of war having been made and thus without the need for Congressional approval. Had Congress been able to voice opinion from the outset then the bloodshed would have been markedly less. Supporters of the resolution stated that a string of presidents had slowly but surely stolen powers related to war from Congress and the resolution would right a severe wrong. The Constitution of the...

...

In his book The National Security Constitution, Harold Koh writes, "In foreign as well as domestic affairs, the Constitution requires that we be governed by separated institutions sharing foreign policy powers" (Koh 69).
Part II:

Those who opposed the War Powers Act of 1973 questioned whether the resolution was constitutional. The Constitution of the United States, they argue, "confers upon Congress only a narrow piece of war power" (Carter 101). Therefore, legislation which guarantees Congress additional powers is thereby in violation of the Constitution because it gives one body more power than another. They also argue that the "act unconstitutionally delegates legislative powers to authorize war and grants presidents dangerous blank checks to wage war" and that it "invades presidential powers to conduct foreign policy and to function" (Hall). Different groups argue over which group's authority is most impeded, but both sides argue that the Act gives one or the other undue power.

Another aspect that opponents point to when they discuss the War Powers Act is the potential consequences of the legislation. Rather than allow Congress to make a determination regarding whether or not entrance in war is what is best for the nation, the law forces Congress to…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited:

Carter, Stephen L. "The Constitutionality of the War Powers Resolution." Virginia Law Review.

1984. Print.

Grimmett, Richard. War Powers Resolution Presidential Compliance. Washington, D.C.:

Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress, 2008. Print.


Cite this Document:

"Amendment Proposal" (2011, February 23) Retrieved May 1, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/amendment-proposal-121204

"Amendment Proposal" 23 February 2011. Web.1 May. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/amendment-proposal-121204>

"Amendment Proposal", 23 February 2011, Accessed.1 May. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/amendment-proposal-121204

Related Documents

Regardless of the theoretical interpretation of this amendment, the practical effects thus far have been quite clear -- responsibilities and rights not handled by the federal government are left up to state and local governments. One of the most important areas in which this can be seen in action is through the investigation of crime. Because the federal government does not prohibit any state or locality's rights in searching

Some of them may have failed at first, such as Abigail Adams and Mercy Otis, who unsuccessfully lobbied the authors of the U.S. Constitution to include women's rights in the document. Over and above, abolitionist women drew parallels between the conditions of slavery and those of women. Anti-slavery activist Angelina Grimke wrote in 1836: "The investigation of the rights of the slave has led me to a better understanding of

However, while the majority of goods will see an increase in demand when prices decrease, the rate at which demand changes of will vary, and some products may see a faster increase than others (Baye, 2007). Additionally, in a few cases a decreasing price may undermine the value of the product, and may result in a decrease in sales, this is known as a Giffen good (Baye, 2007). Elasticity is

Family Law Amendment (Shared Parental Responsibility) Act U v U [2002] HCA Over the years, the moral fibre of the society has continued to crumble. One of the most affected social units in the society is the family. Spouses exchange vows only to go back on their promise that 'till death do us part.' Children are often at the receiving end of such scenarios since family disintegration often has a negative impact

First Amendment freedom of speech and press The Constitution of the United States has been considered to be one of the most liberal fundamental laws of the democratic institutions. It represents he cornerstone of the modern governance and of the modern state. However, the Constitution as it stands today has been subject to several amendments throughout history as reactions to the challenges faced by the state in time. In this

" The full force and authority of a regular police officer is necessary to make such an intrusion. Yet, such a police officer would not be able to summarily search or seize on the premises of a regular home. The homeless person's effects are; therefore, protected from unlawful search and seizure. Works Cited http://www.questia.com/PM.qst?a=o&d=5020427742 Citron, Eric F. "Right and Responsibility in Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence: The Problem with Pretext." Yale Law Journal 116.5 (2007):